Insurance proceeds for the repair of the debtor’s fire-destroyed house are not considered when calculating impairment to the debtor’s homestead exemption where the debtor had not made any repairs on the house prior to filing for bankruptcy. Waltrip v. Sawyers, No. 20-1130 (8th Cir. July 2, 2021). [Read more…] about Insurance Proceeds Don’t Enter Exemption Impairment Calculation
Trustee Can Avoid Tax Penalty Lien for Benefit of Estate
Under sections 724(a) and 551, the chapter 7 trustee could avoid the penalty portion of a federal tax lien on the debtor’s homestead property and preserve the value of the avoided lien for the benefit of the bankruptcy estate. United States of America v. Warfield, 2021 WL 1530094 (D. Ariz. April 19, 2021) (case no. 3:20-cv-8204). [Read more…] about Trustee Can Avoid Tax Penalty Lien for Benefit of Estate
No Deadline for Lien Avoidance Motion
The debtor was not required to file her motion to avoid a judicial lien while her case was still open, and to assert a homestead exemption in Oklahoma, the debtor need only reside on the property. In re Rose-Brownfield, 2021 WL 809767, No. 18-80342 (Bankr. E.D. Okla. Feb. 22, 2021). [Read more…] about No Deadline for Lien Avoidance Motion
Change of Beneficiary Not Avoidable Transfer
The chapter 7 debtor’s change of beneficiary in his life insurance policy from his employer to his wife was not an avoidable property transfer where the debtor retained his interest in the policy and the transfer did not diminish the bankruptcy estate. Harden v. Harrison (In re Harrison), 2021 WL 739533, No. 19-5730, Adv. Proc. No. 20-113 (Bankr. E.D. N.C. Feb. 22, 2021). [Read more…] about Change of Beneficiary Not Avoidable Transfer
Debtor May Avoid County Tax Foreclosure Sale
A county’s tax sale of the debtor’s farm was avoidable as constructively fraudulent under section 548, where the debtor was insolvent at the time of the title transfer and the tax debt was substantially less than the fair market value of the property. DuVall v. County of Ontario, No.19-20179, Adv. Proc. No. 19-2011 (Bankr. W.D. N.Y. Feb. 18, 2021). [Read more…] about Debtor May Avoid County Tax Foreclosure Sale
Transfer of Funds Divided between Creditor and Creditor’s Agent Fully Avoidable
Garnished wages divided between the creditor and his agent in accordance with their fee agreement were an avoidable transfer in their entirety even though the creditor never received the portion withheld by the agent. Hooker v. Wanigas Credit Union, No. 20-2252 (6th Cir. Jan. 26, 2021) (unpublished).
During the ninety-day preference period,Wanigas Credit Union, through its agent, Shek Law Offices, garnished $884.13 from the debtor’s wages in satisfaction of a judgment Wanigas had against the debtor. Shek retained $452.60 of the garnished wages and sent the remaining $431.53 to Wanigas. After filing for bankruptcy the debtor sought turnover of the funds under section 547(b)(1) as a preferential transfer. Wanigas turned over only the funds it received. It argued that the portion retained by Shek was not subject to turnover because Wanigas never received the funds, and in the alternative, because the funds were subject to an attorney-charging lien. The bankruptcy court denied Wanigas’s motion for summary judgment and ordered the turnover of the funds. The district court granted leave to appeal and affirmed. [Read more…] about Transfer of Funds Divided between Creditor and Creditor’s Agent Fully Avoidable
Lien for Incarceration Costs Is Avoidable Judicial Lien
The State Treasurer’s lien based on a statute authorizing the state to seek reimbursement from a prisoner for the costs of his incarceration was not a statutory lien but a judicial lien which the debtor could avoid as impairing his exemptions. State Treasurer v. Wigger, No. 19-732 (W.D. Mich. Nov. 16, 2020).
The debtor was a prisoner in the Central Michigan Correctional Facility. The Michigan State Treasurer sought to recover some of the costs of his incarceration under the State Correctional Facility Reimbursement Act (SCFRA). After a bench trial, the state court found the State Treasurer was entitled to reimbursement from the debtor’s IRA funds and from proceeds from a judgment the debtor had against his son. The debtor initiated a chapter 7 bankruptcy and filed an adversary proceeding seeking to have the state’s lien voided as a judicial lien impairing his exemptions under section 522(f)(1). The bankruptcy court granted the debtor’s lien avoidance motion finding that the lien impaired his exemption for retirement funds under section 522(d)(12), and his exemption for property valued up to $13,100 under section 522(d)(5). [Read more…] about Lien for Incarceration Costs Is Avoidable Judicial Lien
Proceeds from Sale of Fraudulently Transferred Property May Be Recovered from Third Party
The chapter 7 trustee may “recover money from the entity who received the proceeds from the sale of fraudulently transferred property, but to whom the property itself was never transferred.” Rajala v. Husch Blackwell LLP, No. 08-20957, Adv. Proc. No. 18-6016; Rajala v. Spencer Fane LLP, Adv. Proc. No. 18-6020 (Bankr. D. Kans. Aug. 14, 2019).
Three couples started GRHC, a company designed to explore the possibilities of wind-generated electricity. GRHC initiated a wind-energy project in Pennsylvania called Lookout Windpower. The three couples then created the Lookout Windpower Holding Company (LWHC) and transferred Lookout Windpower from GRHC to LWHC rendering GRHC insolvent. LWHC then sold Lookout Windpower to Edison Mission Energy for over $6.7 million, and GRHC filed for chapter 7 bankruptcy. From the Lookout Windpower sale proceeds, LWHC paid the law firms of Husch Blackwell over $1.3 million and Spencer Fane over $700,000. The trustee in GRHC’s bankruptcy case successfully avoided the transfer of Lookout Windpower from GRHC to LWHC and sought to recover the funds paid to the law firms out of the proceeds from LWHC’s subsequent sale of the property. The law firms moved to dismiss the adversary complaints.
[Read more…] about Proceeds from Sale of Fraudulently Transferred Property May Be Recovered from Third PartyAvoidability of Tuition Payments Depends on Timing
Once tuition funds became non-refundable, the universities receiving them would be considered initial transferees, and the transfers would be subject to avoidance under section 550(a). Pergament v. Brooklyn Law School, Nos. 18-2204, 18-2235, 18-2236 (E.D. N.Y. amended opinion Jan. 4, 2019).
In three adversary proceedings, the Chapter 7 Trustee, Marc Pergament, sought to recover tuition payments the debtor, Harold Adamo, made for his children’s education in three universities. The bankruptcy court found that the trustee could not avoid the transfers because the institutions were subsequent transferees who took in good faith under section 550(b). [Read more…] about Avoidability of Tuition Payments Depends on Timing
Rooker-Feldman No Bar to Exercise of Trustee’s Strong-Arm Power
The Sixth Circuit agreed with the position advanced in NACBA / NCBRC’s amicus brief that the Rooker-Feldman doctrine does not preclude application of the trustee’s strong-arm power to avoid a lien notwithstanding a state court judgment of foreclosure. Isaacs v. DBI-ASG Coinvestor Fund III, LLC (In re Isaacs), No. 17-5815 (6th Cir. July 18, 2018).
Linda Isaacs and her husband entered into a mortgage agreement with GMAC Mortgage Corporation. The contract provided in the “description of security” that “By signing this Mortgage, we hereby mortgage, grant and convey [the collateral],” and, in the “priority of advances” section, that “The lien of this Mortgage will attach on the date this mortgage is recorded.” Shortly after signing the agreement, Ms. Isaacs filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy. She scheduled GMAC as a secured creditor, not realizing that it had not yet recorded the mortgage. GMAC recorded the mortgage while the automatic stay was in effect. Ten years after Ms. Isaacs obtained her Chapter 7 discharge, the successor to GMAC sought an order of foreclosure against the Isaacs. The state court issued a default order of foreclosure, and one day before the scheduled sale, Ms. Isaacs filed for Chapter 13 bankruptcy. [Read more…] about Rooker-Feldman No Bar to Exercise of Trustee’s Strong-Arm Power